Form Dates | Admission Criteria | Results | Fee Details | List of All Schools
|
|||||||||||
Tags:
The verdict is a welcome note. 6-14 years age group is not covered in the verdict. But this must be changed to the school specific entry class. Otherwise children admitted at 3+/4+5+ will not allow 6-14 years age group to enjoy the benefit of RTE in full view.
Change in the RTE ambit is of course needed. Govt. should look into the matter immediately and not wait for next year's admission process or wait for someone to file PIL again at the later stage.
Therefore, it is high time for the social jurists and the government too to revise the point system and the ambit of RTE covering every school irrespective of their status being a minority or else.
Who is the beneficiary of the High Court decision?
a. Federation of schools
b. Children
c. Government
Further as per the decision, it seems a directive has been issued by court that, admission must take place again at the age 6+ in all aided and unaided schools. If this is not done then the interpretation of High Court decision must be challenged as per RTE act.
The parents/ grand parents of the children admitted under EWS category, must be directed to submit copy of their Income tax return every year along with affidavit that they are still under EWS category.
In case a family is in or out of EWS at any stage later during the child's education, whether the child will be scrutinized and re-admitted under new status. What is the stand of RTE in such a situation? court has also not given any clarification
Mr. Vaibhav, EWS parents will not submit IT return because they will ask the meaning of IT return. "We don't know what it is!" Sorry, we are non-matric and doing labour/daily wages. They will not give you PAN no. even.
However, we can ask copy of PAN no. from bank in which child has been asked to open the account or Income Tax Deptt. should be asked to enquire all such details.
There should be clear policy in case income limit exceeds the existing Rs. 1 lac/year, then what is to be done for those students studying under EWS category. Whether they should be brought in general category and be charged fee as per general category or otherwise.
Schools are not at fault because they are compelled to admit only on the basis of documents submitted and not allowed to carryout physical verification and take dire decisions.
Now please elaborate your views on my quote.
when I was filling form for my child, I have seen lots of people in line submitting EWS form, their attitude, wearing talking nature doesn't show that they are not less educated to understand the meaning of PAN Card. Can you believe that whose family income is less that 1 lac /year can afford a bike. Yes you are true that actual EWS category people are really don't have any knowledge for filling ITR. But as what I have servayed in 2011, they are not willing to admit their kids in public school, as they are in fear of change of mindset of their kids, so they willing them to be in MCD schools where they will get option of day meal too. And for your information, as servayed by some newspaper in 2010 EWS seats emptied were near 31000 and in 2011 the seats were 29000 (a cutting I have already posted in my previous post). Dramatically in 2012 this figure reduced to 7500, I by that I believe that this year it should be 3000 (as there will be 5% schools who actually go for real admission) only. How could a mind set change in a year. Even you go to slum area of Delhi, meet people and talk to them they still like their kids in MCD schools.
I have already share lots of data last year regarding this, but at end we are in India and more prescribly in Delhi. Nothing will going to happen.
You can't get what Vaibhav has said, he need a system to check the validity of EWS category. The EWS certificate can be procured by some unofficial system. So there should be another check over that. And if govt. wants then it took only a year for them to provide a PAN card to every person under EWS category in Delhi as they are accessible to provide EWS certificate, direct cash system and Adhar to them. But only if they like.
But Sir, most of the schools are not confirming about 2 list. and their websites are also updated as 2 list (IF ANY)..? except SummerField.
My ward is securing 75 points in Summerfield.....is there any chance to get the admission in IInd list...?
Dear Sakshiji and fellow parents!
I came to this forum to learn admission procedures! Every piece of information available in this forum contributed by all of you are valuable and informative.
Now I am forced to complain about the spamming of certain news in this forum which indirectly tells parents to buy management seats even though it doesn't say so directly. For eg., you can find surrogate ads running for cigarettes and liquors but at the end of it, you could find a frame of a water bottle.
I have even seen others complaining about the same issue.
I AM AGAINST OF BUYING A SEAT PAYING MONEY FOR IT. Hence this message disturbs me.
Please tell me, don't you have a set of rules to follow for the members of this forum set by you?
In case if you have, what is it and when will you implement it?
DONT BOTHER, DONT INTERVENE, MY MESSAGE IS NOT ADDRESSED TO YOU.
IS THERE ANY PLAN TO APPEAL IN HO. SUPREME COURT?
Yes Shefali.. The SC appeal in a weeks time as per Adv Ashok Agarwal.
This is what he has to say:
“We have decided to take dual action. One, we will go to the Supreme Court saying that RTE act covers 0-14 yrs and not 6-14 yrs. So HC cannot uphold the Centre’s stand. Two, we will also file a challenge against the High Court’s judgement next week,” Agarwal said.
Dear Mr. Jain,
You are absolutely right that one who has invested money should also get return out of this. At least you have admitted that School are opened by these people to earn money not for social cause as they often claim. Even if Schools are doing business are they not earnign from fees, development charges and so on.. and what about the land which is basically of Govt.(who is servant of citizens of India) not of Schools, which has been provided to School for almost free by the Govt. who levies taxes to us. Nexus between School and Govt. is exposed from your statement.
As per RTE there can be no screening for admission if child is 6+ (suppose class Ist) then it is logical that a child can not be promoted from KG to 1st, as he/she has already been screened at entry level.
1) Hence for admission to class 1st should be conducted afresh for children which were admitted in nursery/KG after screening. Here new/outside children can also apply without any restriction.
OR
2) RTE should be amended so as to apply to admission at entry level whatever age the child may be.
There can not be any other option !
Let the Govt. choose out of these two possible options, what it wants to do.
Govt. can not keep on indulging in logomachy & choose convenient & often illogical options.
SLP in Hon'ble SC should be filed to scrap promotion from KG to 1st then see how / what Govt replies. To save parents from hardship of readmission Govt will amend RTE to entry level else admission will be done at 1st class only as per RTE.
© 2025 Created by Sumit Vohra (Webmaster).
Powered by
helpdesk@admissionsnursery.com